Spotlight on Open RAN | TelecomDrive.com
When you see the many announcements around innovation in OpenRAN for 5G, what you may not realize is that the 4G and 5G-only OpenRAN approach is only suited for greenfield deployments.
So, what does that mean for brownfield or existing wireless networks? There are only two prominent greenfield networks in the world: Rakuten and Dish. The rest of the world has legacy 2G, 3G, and even 4G – and as we are aware these legacy deployments are not OpenRAN.
The new greenfield deployments are going for the OpenRAN-powered network deployment approach for obvious reasons. The OpenRAN solution is well suited for greenfield 4G or 5G deployments as it leads to faster deployment and, at the same time, allows the operator to future-proof their investment. The software-enabled network simplifies expansions and makes it easy for operators with greenfield networks to scale their new networks. The new network is software upgradeable and does away with the cost and complexity of transitioning the networks to 5G.
But what about all these mobile operators with the legacy 2G, 3G, 4G deployments? What is the best way for them to move to 5G and open up their RAN? They need to look at the overall network TCO across their legacy and 5G deployments and use 5G as an opportunity to improve their TCO. Let us have a look at what happens to a mobile operator’s TCO if they deploy OpenRAN for 5G only alongside their 2G, 3G and even 4G legacy network without considering OpenRAN for legacy or as we say for ALL G …
It is important to emphasize here that 2G & 3G networks are not going away anytime soon. Some countries are switching off 2G, some are switching off 3G, but the majority of the world will still have a combination of 2G, 3G, 4G, and 5G networks for years to come. The GSMA mobile economy report 2020 mentioned that 5% of the global population will still use 2G in 2025. That still amounts to over 360 million users. 4G will be still dominating technology in 2025 as well.
In emerging economies, specifically across Africa, parts of Europe and Latin America, many operators still utilize substantial 2G and 3G investments. The migration from legacy to 4G and 5G networks will be a key challenge in those regions since the telecom industries there are still emerging, and an implementation of 4G and 5G could prove very costly because it will require running old legacy non-IP networks and new all IP (4G and 5G) at the same time. In many of the regions across Africa and Latin America, the replacement rate of cellular devices is much lower than in other regions of the world. As mobile phones that are compliant with legacy 2G and 3G tend to be used more in emerging regions, the operators require a solution that can support both 2G and 3G solutions while simultaneously preparing for the deployment of faster 4G and 5G networks. Open RAN solutions that support 2G, 3G, 4G and 5G will cost-effectively enable connectivity in those markets by simplifying installation and providing technological flexibility and sustainability.
For each operator, the landscape of technologies they must support is very heterogeneous; one solution will not fit all scenarios. A sustainable mobile broadband will become widely available with Open RAN, reducing the cost structure and delivering flexibility by design to sustainably evolve and adapt the network to user demand: 2G and 3G today, 4G and 5G in the future.
In developed economies, US mobile operators were looking at Open RAN for rural at first, but current geopolitics around Chinese vendors have created a much bigger opportunity for Open RAN for their 4G brownfield networks. There are smaller US operators like Inland Cellular that are already expanding their 4G networks with Open RAN, proving that it is a strong contender for any RAN replacements if it addresses ALL Gs.
In Europe, Vodafone is leading the Open RAN pack, considering deploying it all across their European operations. Recently, Yago Tenorio, Vodafone’s head of network strategy, confirmed that “we have had trials taking commercial traffic for about a year now,” and “It is a 2G, 3G and 4G trial and it is live and the KPIs (key performance indicators) are really good and in some cases better than the incumbent.”
In a nutshell, if a mobile operator only deploys OpenRAN for 5G, they will have the challenge of managing two networks: a vertical one with legacy equipment and the new one with distributed, OpenRAN architecture. While the operator might have flexibility and will avoid vendor lock-in for 5G, the legacy network will still rely on closed RAN components. How does that approach fit into a promise of OpenRAN avoiding vendor lock-in and reducing cost? It doesn’t, unless OpenRAN can replace legacy Gs as well. This way, ALL the RAN network components for ALL of the Gs will be open and virtualized. Leading global operators using OpenRAN to modernize their legacy networks estimate their return on the modernization investment will be returned in 3 years and will help them to deploy 5G cost-effectively.
And the ones that only deploy OpenRAN for 5G without rethinking their overall network strategy, including legacy Gs? Though they might see short-term CAPEX savings in deployment of OpenRAN for 4G and 5G compared to the equipment from legacy 4G and 5G vendors, their overall OPEX will be 30-50% higher, as older Gs are not as power-efficient or easy to maintain. Long term gain can be only seen if ALL Gs will become OpenRAN while mobile networks move to 5G.
Let us explain why in more detail. As we know, the service providers adopt a siloed approach of adding a new layer for every new G. Typically, legacy RAN platforms are based on proprietary hardware and depend on prolonged and costly lifecycles in development, deployment, and operation. The siloed approach of adding a new layer for every new technology leads to network complexity and demands high investment in CAPEX and OPEX to maintain. This leads to vendor lock-in and sometimes prevents the mobile operators from keeping pace with the new technology developments. With the launch of the new generation, the radios are replaced with newer versions, which demands substantial investment.
5G offers service providers an opportunity to reimagine the overall network architecture and deploy cost-effective open networks not just for 5G, but for legacy as well.
The telecom infrastructures are already undergoing a rapid transformation towards applications running on Network Functions Virtualization (NFV) or containers. Now it is extending further to the RAN to separate functions, where every vendor offering can interoperate with other products. This allows the operators to explore new business models that promote openness and is built on open principles, which enable service providers to benefit from cloud-scale economies and service agility.
Several global service providers are already opting for OpenRAN architecture across ALL Gs to break from the limitations imposed on them by proprietary radio systems. The OpenRAN network architecture that addresses 2G 3G 4G and 5G, which is programmable, flexible and unbundled, can meet the requirements for improved mobile broadband and extremely low latency for legacy and newer Gs.
The new OpenRAN across ALL G approach allows mobile operators to run just one OpenRAN network. The most significant advantage of the ALL G OpenRAN is that it enables service providers to improve network economics by converging all Gs, including 2G, 3G, 4G, and 5G, on one single software platform. It not only helps in enhancing network simplicity but brings down the cost of managing and maintaining the network. This will allow the unification of legacy brownfield with greenfield so it can be managed as one cloud native ALL IP network.
Latin America is a large geographical region with many areas that are extremely difficult to be reached and concentration of infrastructure and population in large metropolitan areas. During spectrum actions, the government puts expectations on MNOs to cover the majority of geographical areas, not just by population. It presents a challenge to regional MNOs to cover entire countries as the cost of installation and maintenance of traditional RANs is high. Couple it with the need to support a variety of technologies to support 2G 3G 4G and 5G in the future, and no wonder Open RAN is catching on like fire throughout the region.
African MNOs need to optimize their previous G investments, especially 4G as those deployments were delayed due to the ability of end users to pay more for 4G services. At the same time, MNOs in Africa are looking to Open RAN for any new 2G or 3G or 4G deployments: vendor choice, lowest TCO, easy upgradability – will help African MNOs to bring connectivity to more end users. In addition, it will help them to realize network ROI much faster– and that is why 4G-based on Open RAN will become a leading technology in Africa in the years to come as more users get access to 4G devices.
An All G OpenRAN solution was attractive to MTN because of easy upgradability to any G, allowing MTN to keep building 2G networks in areas untouched by wireless connectivity, while at the same time continuing to allocate resources and time to expand their 3G or 4G networks with the same investment. MTN is set to deploy 5,000 OpenRAN sites across their 21 operations.
Orange has recently joined the Open RAN movement and is planning on starting its Open RAN journey in Africa with the goal to roll Open RAN for 2G 3G 4G and eventually 5G out across all of their operations.
And although there are capabilities to deploy 5G, Africa-based operators will require the ability to run 5G alongside their existing 2G, 3G and 4G networks. At present, that can only be solved with either erecting new infrastructure or deploying Open RAN, which can run alongside existing infrastructure. It’s a no brainer really …
5G is a technology change that no service provider in any part of the world would like to miss out on. Even if there are challenges in rolling out 5G services, as there are commercial as well as infrastructural issues related to the mass launch of 5G services, there is no denying that the technology would give a massive boost to the world’s economy. 5G technology, owing to its inherent features like high data speed, low latency, effective use of spectrum, and better coverage, supports a larger number of devices and low energy consumption opens up a whole new number of use cases that will benefit the end users and businesses. It enables service providers to offer myriad innovative services like augmented reality, virtual reality, remote surgery, autonomous transport systems, industrial automation and more.
These 5G functionalities could help deliver services like healthcare and education on a mass scale by side-stepping infrastructural challenges. 5G enables the mobile network to support services including e-learning and e-health, through digital platforms, which is more cost effective and sustainable, but only if legacy Gs are addressed as a part of the overall network strategy.
Parallel Wireless developed OpenRAN for ALL Gs for just this reason. We listened to our customers and their needs and developed OpenRAN technology that addresses ALL Gs, resulting in overall reduced network TCO. 5G is just another tool in the OpenRAN box, but unless ALL Gs become OpenRAN, the true promise of OpenRAN, or 5G itself for that matter, cannot be realized.